Canadian Marine Pilots' Association
   

Guiding Principles -
Pilotage Authority Quality Assurance Programs For Assessing Pilot Proficiency And Quality Of Service

The purpose of this document is to establish common principles that will assist
pilotage authorities as they develop and implement quality assurance programs for
assessing pilot proficiency. The programs are intended to enable authorities to fully
meet Recommendation No. 9 of the CTA’s Ministerial Review of Outstanding Pilotage
Issues
as well as international training and certification standards for maritime pilots
such as the International Maritime Organization’s Resolution A960. The programs will
complement existing systems, practices and procedures and will be designed to ensure
pilotage in Canada remains second to none in terms of safety and efficiency.

These principles will be included in each region’s written procedures for the
assessment of pilot proficiency and performance. They are designed to encourage a
common, constructive and fair-minded approach, although specific practices may vary
from region to region.

Guiding Principles

  • Collaborative: The ultimate responsibility for the quality assurance program
    rests with the Authorities. The program, however, will be developed and
    implemented in partnership with pilots groups.
  • Focus on Quality: the purpose of the program is to foster the best possible
    quality performance by pilots, rather than to be used as a punitive or disciplinary
    tool.
  • Applicability: while, in some cases, the introduction of pilot assessments may be
    gradual, it is the intention that, within a reasonable period of time, assessments
    will apply to all pilots.
  • Frequency: assessments will take place regularly and not less than once every
    three years.
  • Transparency: results of the assessment should be communicated in a timely
    manner to the pilot in question, and the pilot given an opportunity to comment
    before the results are considered final. In those cases where the comments of
    the pilot are not reflected in the final results, the views of the pilot will form an
    integral part of the record.
  • Confidentiality: all assessment results, together with all accompanying
    documentation, will be maintained as part of the pilot’s confidential personnel
    record and access to the material will be governed by the same rules that apply
    to the confidential personnel record as a whole.
  • Modality: pilots’ proficiency can be assessed through various means. No single
    means, however, should be the sole basis upon which an assessment is made.
  • Remedy: in those cases where it is determined that a pilot’s proficiency and/or
    performance needs to be improved, specific and practical steps should be
    identified to ensure the situation is effectively remedied.
  • Precedence of the Pilotage Act: Nothing in the pilotage authority quality
    assurance program for assessing pilot proficiency will take precedence over the
    legislation and regulations which govern the issuance and suspension of pilot
    licenses.